Or
Why Black Karens are not low budget
Karen brought the deeds. Amanda brought the audacity. And apparently, we’re supposed to be offended by the response rather than the provocation.
Let’s get one thing straight. I’m Team Karen.
Not because I believe everything that comes out of Karen Loderick-Peace’s mouth is a masterclass in diplomacy. Far from it. But because having watched the exchange with Amanda Cronin on The Real Housewives of London, I’m rather tired of the familiar spectacle of a white woman starting a fight, a Black woman finishing it, and everyone subsequently clutching their pearls about the Black woman’s aggression.
Amanda, darling, you started it. You just weren’t expecting the full-service response.
When Amanda attempted to diminish Karen by suggesting she lived in a little rented townhouse, Karen didn’t exactly retreat into the background. Instead, she started listing properties. Chelsea. Belgravia. Two in Jersey. Wait, what’s the 5th?
Then came the immortal description of Amanda as a “low-budget vagina”.
Frankly, Amanda should have known better than to start something she wasn’t prepared to finish.
The problem with Black women who talk back
There is a particular phenomenon that happens when a Black woman dresses down a white woman.
It doesn’t matter who started the disagreement. It doesn’t matter who was being condescending, dismissive or downright unpleasant. The moment the Black woman raises her voice, delivers a cutting remark or refuses to back down, the narrative changes.
Suddenly, she’s aggressive.
She’s intimidating.
Or she’s angry.
She’s too much.
The white woman, meanwhile, is frequently recast as the victim of an unnecessarily hostile encounter and the Becky tears start.
It’s an old story. Black women are expected to absorb disrespect with a smile, respond to provocation with grace and maintain an almost superhuman level of composure while somebody else tests their patience.
We must be assertive, but not confrontational. Confident, but not intimidating. Successful, but never boastful. And heaven forbid we demonstrate that we are perfectly capable of giving as good as we get.
Because apparently, a Black woman is allowed to have a backbone, provided she doesn’t actually use it.
Watch the whole exchange rather than simply judging the most outrageous soundbite. There is a difference between initiating an antagonistic exchange and responding to one. Yet that distinction seems to disappear rather conveniently when the woman doing the responding is Black.
Amanda wanted a fight. Karen brought the receipts.
What I particularly enjoyed about Karen’s response was that Amanda appeared to be attempting to establish a hierarchy based on property, wealth and social standing.
The little rented townhouse comment was intended to diminish Karen. It was a rather transparent attempt to position herself above another woman.
And that is what made the exchange so delicious.
Karen wasn’t simply defending her home. She was defending her achievements. There is something particularly satisfying about watching a woman refuse to let somebody else rewrite her success in order to make themselves feel superior.
Amanda appeared to think she could make Karen feel small.
Instead, Karen made sure everyone knew exactly how big her property portfolio was.
As for the low-budget vagina comment? Well, Amanda may want to consider that if you enter a verbal exchange armed with personal insults, you shouldn’t be surprised when somebody returns fire.
The Karen label has a racial problem
Which brings us to the title.
The modern use of Karen isn’t simply another word for an unpleasant woman. It has a particular cultural history, associated with white female entitlement and the weaponisation of racial privilege.
Think of the white woman who calls the police on a Black person for doing something perfectly ordinary. The woman who assumes she has the right to question someone’s presence, demand their removal or enlist authority against them.
The power of the Karen stereotype comes from the racial and institutional dynamics behind that behaviour.
So why are we now so comfortable describing Black women as Karens simply because they are demanding, difficult, loud or occasionally downright unpleasant?
Black women can absolutely be entitled. We can be classist, arrogant, unreasonable and thoroughly objectionable. We don’t get a lifetime exemption from criticism because of our skin colour.
But context matters.
A Black woman challenging a white woman’s condescension isn’t automatically demonstrating the same entitlement as a white woman weaponising racial privilege against a Black person.
And a Black woman refusing to be patronised isn’t necessarily aggressive. Sometimes she’s simply refusing to play the role that somebody else has written for her.
Black women are not required to be everybody’s respectable auntie
There is a wider issue here about the expectation that Black women must always be the bigger person.
We are expected to demonstrate restraint even when somebody else has shown none. We must choose our words carefully, manage everybody else’s feelings and somehow remain dignified while being disrespected.
It’s exhausting.
And it creates an absurd double standard in which the person doing the provoking gets to enjoy the freedom of being outspoken, while the person responding is criticised for being confrontational.
Would Amanda have been described as aggressive if she’d delivered an equally cutting response to Karen? Would we be discussing her tone, her attitude and whether she was being a bully?
Or would we simply call her a woman who knows how to stand up for herself?
That is the question worth asking.
I’m not arguing that Karen’s language was particularly feminist. Reducing another woman’s worth to her vagina isn’t exactly a triumph for women’s solidarity. But I can enjoy Karen’s refusal to be diminished without pretending every word she said was beyond criticism.
Two things can be true.
Team Karen. Obviously.
I don’t need Karen to be perfect to be on her side.
We don’t need her to speak like a member of the House of Lords, nor do I need her to issue a carefully worded statement about the importance of respectful dialogue.
I want to see Black women allowed the same range of human responses as everybody else.
Sometimes we are gracious. Sometimes we are diplomatic. And sometimes we take the high road.
And sometimes, when somebody decides to be unnecessarily patronising, we tell them exactly where to get off.
The important thing is to judge the entire exchange, not just the moment when the Black woman finally loses patience.
Amanda shouldn’t have started something she couldn’t finish.
Karen arrived with her property portfolio, her confidence and apparently a vocabulary that Amanda will be recovering from for some time.
And if the biggest takeaway from that exchange is that Karen was too aggressive, rather than asking why Amanda thought she could speak to her that way in the first place, then perhaps we’re watching two very different programmes.
Karen brought the deeds. Amanda brought the audacity.
And Chelsea Black is firmly Team Karen.
© Chelsea Black ®